Predatory pricing – unfair or just smart business?

Fair business practices 5 Comments

This article focuses on predatory pricing, the use of aggressive pricing strategies in an attempt to eliminate competitors.

Specifically, this article examines two questions – whether or not the practice is ethical and whether or not it should be allowed.

 
What is predatory pricing?

As stated above, “predatory pricing” refers to the practice of large business using aggressive pricing strategies in order to eliminate smaller competitors.

The practice involves price cutting for a short period of time to the extent that profit margins become unsustainable. Often, under this strategy, products or services are sold at below cost.

Large business, with strong balance sheets, can sustain the associated losses for a considerable time period, particularly where losses involved can be subsidized by profits from other product lines. Smaller competitors cannot.

The result – smaller competitors are forced out of business whilst the surviving companies face a less competitive operating environment.

 
Is predatory pricing unethical?

Provided it is done within legal limitations, predatory pricing is not unethical.

Business is a fierce and competitive environment, and where companies have strong balance sheets, they are entitled to use this as a competitive weapon.

Ethical behavior is important, but business is a hard ball game and industry players need not show kindness toward competitors.

If you can’t stand the heat, better stay out of the kitchen.

 
Should it be allowed?

Not in my view. In many countries, predatory pricing is not allowed, and rightly so.

Whilst not unethical, the practice is harmful to the economy in at least three ways:

• It can destroy otherwise viable firms.
• It discourages the entry of otherwise viable firms into the market.
• It can lead to a concentration of power within industries and the creation of monopolies or oligopolies. In the resultant less competitive environment, firms are under less pressure to innovate or improve product quality and customer service.

Accordingly, whilst not unethical in itself, economic considerations dictate that predatory pricing should not be allowed.

5 Responses to “Predatory pricing – unfair or just smart business?”

  1. Predatory pricing: a smart business move? | Social Bridges Says:
    September 3rd, 2008 at 5:59 pm

    [...] from Good Honest Dollar has discussed the phenomenon of aggressive pricing in ample details. Social Bridges is grateful to [...]

  2. Random Approach Says:
    September 10th, 2008 at 11:57 pm

    This article was tagged as “fairness in business practices” and i couldn’t see any other articles tagged same. So this is my opening to same category. I recently started my own blog, and for the first time commercial aspect kept on mind. But as my earlier life has been strongly influenced by ethical issues, i wanted to keep same theme around there.

    What i’d like to hear and discuss is online business ethics and marketing. That is really hard stone to bite. I don’t know other as complicated subjects when talking about ethics in business. Work ethics, environmental issues, fair distribution of income and so on, their are quite clear and practical areas, but how do you define ethical marketing tactics? Do you think it is fair, if someone sells the program with name “google ads for free”, but after you read the manual, you see that they are not actually free, but you can compensate the money spent to adverticing by the money you get from other adverticers?

    Thank you for picking me up from my blog and making my path to yours. I’m going to spend many hours reading the articles here.

  3. drew Says:
    September 12th, 2008 at 9:14 am

    Random Approach,

    Welcome to my blog and thank you for your comment.

    I am not familiar with the program you are referring to, so I am not in a position to make specific reference to that particular situation. (I assume that you are not talking about the way Google itself markets its AdSense program)

    However, as a general rule, any form of advertising which is in any way misleading or deceptive in nature is both illegal and unethical in most countries. Advertisers of all forms have a duty of care to their audience to make only fair and truthful representations of their offering. This is the case in both the online and offline world.

    As I said, I can’t make an informed comment on the situation that you mention, but from your description, it would sound like a breach of ethical duty to the consumer.

    Cheers

    Andrew

  4. Ken@High yield cds. Says:
    December 16th, 2008 at 2:33 am

    Predatory pricing has gone on a long time. I do not agree with it but alot of companies will drive anyone than can out of business if they can do it. Just think about walmart or any other big chain and how they drive prices down and make small stores go under. They then can raise prices back when all competitors in small towns are gone.

  5. Andrew Says:
    December 20th, 2008 at 8:55 pm

    Absolutely right, Ken.

    At best, the practice is anti-competitive in nature, and if left unchecked, it will allow for the development of uncompetitive monopolies.

    Andrews last blog post..A personal note on last week’s post

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv Enabled
Icons by N.Design Studio. Designed By Ben Swift. Powered by WordPress and Free WordPress Themes
Entries RSS